Sign in
Reddit science
Tuesday, February 18
1
Using scented products indoors changes the chemistry of the air, producing as much air pollution as car exhaust does outside, according to a new study. Researchers say that breathing in these nanosized particles could have serious health implications.
Discussion
Using scented products indoors, such as flame-free candles and wax melts, can create significant indoor air pollution comparable to car exhaust. Research by Purdue University found these products release nanosized particles that can penetrate deep into lungs and potentially enter the bloodstream, posing serious respiratory health risks.
Misleading title scope
Discussion about how study only focused on wax melts but title suggests all scented products, with debate about whether findings could logically extend to other scented items
Health concerns from chemist
A chemist's perspective against using scented products leads to sharing of personal health impact stories, from COPD to cancer cases, and debate about necessity of artificial scents
Air purification solutions
Discussion of HEPA filters and other air purification methods as solutions, with debate about effectiveness against different types of pollutants like VOCs and nanoparticles
2
Trump assassination attempt lowered Republican support for violence and boosted party unity | An event that many feared would widen political divides appeared to have a unifying effect on Republicans without stoking extra hostility toward the opposing party.
Discussion
Research shows the July 2024 attempted assassination of Trump didn't increase support for partisan violence. Instead, Republicans became less inclined to support violence against Democrats and felt more united. Democrats' attitudes remained stable, though the decrease in Republican support for violence was temporary.
Shooter's political affiliation
Discussion about the shooter being Republican and how this fact was either unknown or denied by many Republicans, with debate about whether this affected the narrative and media coverage
Suspicious circumstances
Multiple users questioning unusual aspects of the assassination attempt, including limited media coverage, Trump's rapid ear healing, and comparing it to other historical staged attacks
Impact on party unity
Discussion of how the event united Republicans without increasing hostility toward Democrats, possibly because Republican hostility toward Democrats was already at maximum levels
3
Adults who have experienced depression develop long-term physical conditions about 30% faster than those without depression. Authors of the report said depression needs to be viewed as a “whole body” condition, with treatment approaches that address mental and physical health.
Discussion
A study found that adults with depression develop physical conditions 30% faster than those without it. Depression sufferers had more conditions like osteoarthritis, hypertension, and GERD. Researchers suggest depression should be viewed as a whole-body condition requiring integrated healthcare approaches.
Depression as whole-body condition
Research shows depression affects entire body through inflammation markers, gut microbiome changes, and physical health. Study found depressed people develop conditions 30% faster, highlighting need for comprehensive treatment.
Vicious cycles
Multiple users describe self-reinforcing loops between depression and physical issues - pain triggering depression which worsens pain, weight gain fueling depression leading to more weight gain, and lack of exercise affecting mental health.
Treatment approach
Discussions emphasize need for holistic treatment covering both mental and physical health, with calls for changes in insurance coverage and healthcare policy to reflect connection between mind and body.
4
Ketamine-assisted psychotherapy helps rage-filled middle-aged man overcome antisocial traits and severe alcoholism - Over a three-year period, this treatment helped him overcome severe alcohol abuse, ease deep feelings of depression, and reduce his harmful, antisocial thoughts.
Discussion
This case report details how a middle-aged man with severe alcohol abuse, depression, and antisocial personality disorder showed significant improvement through ketamine-assisted psychotherapy over three years, reducing his harmful behaviors and thoughts while achieving sobriety.
Elon Musk criticism
Multiple commenters point out Musk as a counterexample where ketamine hasn't helped, noting his erratic behavior and suggesting his recreational use differs from therapeutic application with proper medical oversight.
Treatment effectiveness
Debate over whether single case study proves ketamine's efficacy, with some questioning if therapy alone helped while others cite broader evidence of ketamine's success in treating depression.
Access barriers
Discussion of difficulties accessing ketamine treatment due to requirements to try other medications first, high costs, and system restrictions, despite its potential benefits.
5
Americans more tolerant of anti-democratic actions when their party controls the White House - The research indicates that both Democrats and Republicans show a tendency to support behaviors that erode democratic principles when their own party controls the presidency.
Discussion
False equivalence
Many commenters criticize the study for equating GOP's rejection of election results with Democrats' desire to expand Supreme Court, viewing this as an unfair "both sides" comparison that normalizes anti-democratic behavior
Supreme Court expansion debate
Discussion on whether expanding SCOTUS is undemocratic, with arguments about constitutionality, court packing concerns, and suggestions for term limits vs. lifetime appointments
Study credibility
Questions raised about study's peer review status, potential political bias, and whether foreign researchers can effectively analyze US democratic norms
6
New study reveals that sleep prevents unwanted memories from intruding: « Sleep problems play an important role in the onset and maintenance of many mental health problems, but the reason for this link is elusive. »
Discussion
A new study from the University of East Anglia reveals that sleep helps prevent unwanted memories from intruding into consciousness by engaging brain regions that control memory suppression. Research shows that well-rested individuals have better ability to control unwanted thoughts, with REM sleep playing a crucial role in restoring prefrontal control mechanisms.
Brain cleaning during sleep
Discussion of glymphatic system and brain cleaning mechanisms during sleep, including role of cerebrospinal fluid, oligodendrocytes and other processes, though exact mechanisms remain uncertain
Sleep deprivation effects
Personal experiences with lack of sleep leading to irritability, memory issues, rumination, and mental health challenges, including discussion of insomnia's impact on daily functioning and emotional regulation
Scientific mechanisms
Technical discussion of how sleep affects brain chemistry, including HPA axis regulation, neurotransmitters, and hormones, linking sleep disruption to various mental health conditions
7
Women’s bodies are moralized more than men’s, study finds | This tendency to moralize women’s bodies could help explain why society often places stricter controls and judgments on women’s bodies compared to men’s.
Discussion
Research shows that society tends to view women's bodies through a moral lens more than men's bodies, leading to stricter controls and judgments on women's bodily autonomy. This moral scrutiny extends to various behaviors like public toplessness and is influenced by sexist beliefs.
Study methodology criticism
Multiple users critique the small sample size (470), biased participant selection, and questionable methodology. Scientists express concern about weak peer review standards in social sciences.
Reproductive biology impact
Discussion focuses on how women's ability to get pregnant leads to stricter societal controls and moral judgments, including healthcare access and bodily autonomy restrictions.
Research value debate
Users debate whether studying obvious social phenomena has value, with some arguing for importance of scientific documentation while others dismiss it as unnecessary.
8
Men who reported higher levels of socially-prescribed perfectionism had partners who reported higher levels of sexual distress. This suggests that when men feel pressured to be perfect by others, it may contribute to negative sexual experiences for their partners.
Discussion
A study in The Journal of Sex Research found that individuals with high personal standards experience stronger desire for their partners, while those feeling pressured by others' expectations show lower sexual function and higher distress, with potential spillover effects on their partners.
Performance anxiety
Multiple users share experiences of how perfectionism and anxiety negatively impact sexual experiences, with several noting that being more relaxed and less focused on performance led to better encounters.
Gender perspectives
Debate about how societal expectations affect men vs women differently, with some viewing the study as gender-biased while others argue it reveals important insights about how perfectionism impacts both partners.
Research validity
Discussion of the study's methodology and findings, focusing on how socially-prescribed perfectionism affects sexual relationships and partner distress over time.
9
Reintroducing wolves to Scottish Highlands could help address climate emergency | Control of red deer by wolves could lead to an expansion of native woodland that would take up - or sequester - one million tonnes of CO2 each year - equivalent to approximately 5% of the carbon removal
Discussion
A University of Leeds study suggests reintroducing wolves to the Scottish Highlands could help expand native woodlands and store one million tonnes of CO2 annually. The research estimates 167 wolves could control red deer populations, enabling natural tree regeneration and contributing to UK's 2050 net-zero goals, with each wolf potentially providing £154,000 worth of carbon storage benefits.
Yellowstone comparison
While wolves helped restore Yellowstone's ecosystem, Scotland's situation differs due to smaller wilderness areas, more human settlements, and infrastructure built assuming wolves' extinction.
Sheep predation concerns
Farmers oppose wolf reintroduction fearing sheep losses. Solutions like compensation schemes and guard dogs are proposed, with Dutch experience showing significant livestock attacks.
Hunting alternative
Suggestions to manage deer through hunting face resistance from locals opposed to American hunters, while others note hunting differs from natural predation in target selection.
10
Water chlorination levels in US and EU likely increase cancer risk, study finds - Bladder cancer risk increased 33% and colorectal cancer by 15% in using chlorine to disinfect water.
Discussion
A systematic review and meta-analysis examined links between drinking water trihalomethanes (THMs) and cancer risk. Analysis of multiple studies found increased risks for bladder and colorectal cancers associated with THM exposure, with significant risks for bladder cancer above 41μg/L. The findings suggest current US and EU regulatory limits may not adequately protect against cancer risk in the general population.
Title accuracy correction
Multiple experts point out the study examines trihalomethane byproducts of chlorination, not chlorine itself, making the post title misleading. THMs are already monitored and regulated.
Risk vs benefit analysis
Discussion weighs slight increased cancer risk (1% to 1.33%) against major benefits of preventing waterborne diseases. Consensus that chlorination's benefits outweigh risks.
Water treatment methods
Experts discuss alternatives like UV treatment and home filtration, noting chlorine remains most practical for maintaining water safety through distribution systems due to its residual disinfecting properties.
Subscribe to Reddit science Sumcast
Subscribe